x

x

Terms and Conditions
Introduction
Welcome to TONGUES, provided by Voodoo Voodoo Ltd (“we”, “us”, “our”). Access to and use of this website (“TONGUES”) is provided by us on the basis of a number of important terms and conditions, which are set out in full below.
You should carefully read these terms and conditions (“terms”). When you use TONGUES, you will be legally bound by these terms, which will take effect from your first use of TONGUES. If you do not agree to be legally bound by these terms, then you should not use TONGUES>.
These terms apply generally to the use of TONGUES. Any facility (“Comment Facility”) that we may make accessible to you through TONGUES, enabling you to post messages, comments, information, material or content (a “Contribution”), may have additional special terms attached. If and when a Comment Facility becomes available, you will need to read and agree to be legally bound by those special terms before you post a Contribution or use those sections. If you do not agree to be legally bound by those special terms then you will not be able to post a Contribution.
TONGUES is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in a country where that distribution or use would be contrary to local laws or regulations.
Changes to Terms
We are continually seeking to update and improve TONGUES. As a result, we may make changes to TONGUES, including these terms, at any time. You will need to review these terms regularly so that you are aware of any changes we have made. You will be legally bound by the updated or amended terms from the first time that you use TONGUES after we post the changes on-line.
TONGUES Content
The rights in materials, images, information, data, trade marks, trade names and logos and other content included on TONGUES (“TONGUES content”) are are owned by us or the relevant third party content owner. All rights are reserved and acknowledged. As TONGUES content is protected by a variety of third party rights, you may not copy, adapt, re-publish, make available to the public or print off copies of TONGUES content in any way, or use it other than as part of TONGUES and for your personal non-commercial use, without our prior written permission.
Information
Information which we provide through TONGUES is in outline for information or entertainment purposes only. You should not rely on it.
Third party websites
We do not monitor the content of third party websites and any link provided on TONGUES is solely for your convenience. We cannot therefore accept any responsibility for any third party website. You are responsible for checking and complying with the terms and privacy policies applicable to your use of any third party website.
Responsibility
The extent of our responsibility to you has been determined in the context of the following:
access to TONGUES is provided to you free of charge;
it is your responsibility to determine the suitability of any TONGUES content for any particular purpose to which you wish to put it;
TONGUES does not give instructions and you are responsible for any action or decision you take or do not take as a result of TONGUES content;
It is your responsibility to ensure that your equipment is enabled with appropriate up-to-date virus checking software before you access or use TONGUES.
Whilst we will endeavour to ensure that TONGUES is available to you and that content for which we are responsible is accurate, we cannot make any legal commitment or representation to you that TONGUES will be available at any particular time or that it or any TONGUES content will be of any particular quality or fit for any particular purpose. However, we will exercise reasonable skill and care in providing any service to you.
We can accept no liability to you for any of the following types of loss (should you suffer any of them as a result of your use of TONGUES):
loss which was not foreseeable to you and us when you first accessed or registered to use TONGUES (even if that loss results from the our failure to comply with these terms or our negligence);
any business loss you may suffer, including loss of revenue, profits or anticipated savings (whether those losses are the direct or indirect result of our default);
loss which you suffer other than as a result of our failure to comply with these terms or our negligence or breach of statutory duty;
any loss suffered due to the default of any party other than us.
We do not give any commitment that TONGUES or any TONGUES content will be available uninterrupted or error free, that defects will be corrected, or that TONGUES or its supporting systems are free of viruses or bugs.
We can accept no liability to you if we fail, or are interrupted or delayed in the performance of any obligation because of:
the non-availability or failure of any telecommunications or computer services, systems, equipment or software operated or provided by you or any third party;
any other event not reasonably within our control.
We do not give any commitments or accept any liability to you in respect of TONGUES content provided by other users of the website or third parties other than us.
Nothing in these terms will limit our liability for death or personal injury arising from our negligence.
Remedies
To the extent that we are practically able to do so, we may terminate your access to any part of TONGUES at any time without notice if you breach any of the terms.
General
If any of these terms are determined to be illegal, invalid or otherwise unenforceable then the remaining terms shall remain in full force and effect.
These terms shall be governed by and interpreted in accordance with the laws of England and Wales. If you are a consumer, then you may have rights to bring court proceedings in the courts of the country in which you are domiciled. Otherwise, to the fullest extent permitted by law, you and we shall bring all court proceedings in the courts of England and Wales.
© TONGUES — An initiative by Voodoo Voodoo Ltd

x

Privacy & Cookies Policy
Introduction
The tongues.cc website is operated by Voodoo Voodoo Ltd (‘TONGUES’).
This privacy policy applies to TONGUES.
We want you to enjoy our website and services secure in the knowledge that we have implemented fair information practices to protect your privacy. By visiting our website, you are accepting the practices described in our privacy policy, including our use of cookies and similar online tracking technologies. If you do not agree to the terms of this privacy policy, please do not use the website.
TONGUES may change this policy from time to time by updating this page and you should regularly check to ensure that you are happy with any changes. This policy was last updated on 11 February 2020.
The policy outlines:
1. General principle
2. How we collect information
3. Types of information we may collect
4. How we use your information
5. How we protect the information we collect
6. Access to your personal information
7. How to contact us
1. General principle
There are two types of information we may collect from you when you use the website: non-personally identifiable information and personally identifiable information. Non-personally identifiable information does not individually identify you, but it may include tracking and usage information about your general location, demographics, use of the website and the internet. Personally identifiable information is information that you voluntarily provide when you set up a user account, subscribe to a newsletter, or query that can individually identify you and may include your name and email address etc.
We do not link non-personally identifiable information to your personally identifiable information.
We do not share either type of information unless required to run the website and services (see third-party services below). We will never sell either type of information.
This privacy policy does not apply to any information collected outside of the website, including offline or through other means (for example, via telephone or through email), unless otherwise stated below or at the time of collection.
2. How we collect information
We collect information when you:
— Ask to be placed on an email newsletter list
Make an enquiry about our services
— Answer a reader survey
— Provide information to us
Links to other websites, social media platforms
Our website may contain links to other websites of interest. However, once you have used these links to leave our website, you should note that we do not have any control over the information that is collected and shared about you. You should exercise caution and look at the privacy statement applicable to the website in question.
You may interact with content on our website through social media platforms we use such as Facebook by using their social features. Examples of social features include ‘liking’ or ‘sharing’ our content. We encourage you to review their policies before using their tools, which can be found at their respective websites. If you’d prefer that these social media platforms do not collect information about the content you share and use, we suggest that you don’t use their tools.
3. Types of information we may collect
The types of information we may collect includes:
— Account information (email address)
— Information you provide through a TONGUES reader survey which might include age range, education level etc
TONGUES is not responsible for any information you have provided in public areas of our website or on our social media platforms, which may then be viewed by other users.
4. How we use your information
The information we collect may be used to help us:
— Provide services you voluntarily subscribed to such as email newsletters
— Improve the quality of our website
— Promote services to you including advising you of updates or changes to our website and services
— Improve the website through reader surveys and feedback
Disclosure to third-party services
As part of providing our website and services to you we use a limited number of third-party services that perform functions on our behalf, including but not limited to website hosting, server monitoring, tracking user behaviour, marketing automation services, and customer service.
We have no control over, and assume no responsibility for, the conduct, practices or privacy policies of these third-party services and encourage you to read the policies of the services we use below:
TONGUES uses the MailerLite marketing automation service to issue newsletters. Find out more about MailerLite’s Privacy Policy and Terms.
When you subscribe to our email newsletters
By clicking ‘Subscribe’ you agree to the following: 
We will use the email address you provide to send you a weekly or monthly email. We also send occasional updates and, no more than once a year, reader surveys. 
The email address/es you provide will be transferred to our external marketing automation service ‘MailerLite’ for processing in accordance with their Privacy Policy and Terms. We use MailerLite to issue our newsletters. We have no control over, and assume no responsibility for, the conduct, practices or privacy policies of MailerLite
Unsubscribing
You can change your mind at any time by clicking the ‘unsubscribe link’ in the footer of emails you receive from us, or by contacting us at [email protected]. If you want to review and correct the personal information we have about you, you can click on ‘update preferences’ in the footer of emails you receive from us, or by contacting us at [email protected].
5. How we protect the information we collect
We are committed to ensuring that your information is secure. We have taken reasonable measures to protect information about you from loss, theft, misuse or unauthorised access, disclosure, alteration and destruction. No physical or electronic security system is impenetrable however and you should take your own precautions to protect the security of any personally identifiable information you transmit. We cannot guarantee that the personal information you supply will not be intercepted while transmitted to us or third-party service providers. 
Sharing your personal information
We will not disclose your personal information except; (1) as described by this Privacy Policy (2) after obtaining your permission to a specific use or disclosure or (3) if we are required do so by a valid legal process or government request (such as a court order, a search warrant, a subpoena, a civil discovery request, or a statutory requirement). We will retain your information for as long as needed in light of the purposes for which it was obtained or to comply with our legal obligations and enforce our agreements. 
Data transfer
This website is published in the United Kingdom. If you are located in a country outside of these countries and voluntarily submit personally identifiable information to us, you should be aware that information about you will be transferred to this countries. We attempt to comply with local data protection laws to the extent that they may apply to TONGUES. 
Age of consent
Our website is not directed at children under the age of 18 and we do not knowingly collect or maintain information from those we know are younger than 18. If you are younger than 18, you should not submit or post any personally identifiable information to our website. By using the Service, you represent that you are at least 18 years of age.
6. Access to your personal information
You may request a copy of the personal information we hold about you by submitting a written request to [email protected]. We may only implement requests with respect to the personal information associated with the particular email address you use to send us the request. We will try and respond to your request as soon as reasonably practical. When you receive the information, if you think any of it is wrong or out of date, you can ask us to change or delete it for you. 
We take all reasonable steps to ensure the information held is accurate, up-to-date, complete, relevant and not misleading. 
7. Contact us
If you have any questions about our privacy policy or our use of your information, please contact us at [email protected].

Francisco Berzunza

December 14 / 2023

x

Francisco Berzunza is a historian based in Mexico City. He has curated exhibitions with Slavs and Tatars, Dexter Dalwood and Alfredo Jaar amongst others. His latest show, ‘You to Me, Me to You’, ran at A4 Arts Foundation in Cape Town earlier this year. 

The exhibition marks a return for Berzunza from his home in Mexico, to South Africa. Having lived in Cape Town in 2014 and again in 2016, Berzunza became intimately connected to the city and its artistic practitioners. On his return to Mexico, he determined to begin a dialogue between artistic communities working from and around these two countries. His efforts produced the first iteration of Hacer Noche (Crossing Night) in Oaxaca, 2018, which asked after practices of death and commemoration. Artists Georgina Gratrix, Jo Ractliffe, Kemang Wa Lehulere, Moshekwa Langa, Pieter Hugo, and James Webb were among the artists present in Hacer Noche and Berzunza invited them to participate in ‘You to Me, Me to You’.

Berzunza sits on the Development Committee Board of the UK’s National Gallery and advises financial institutions in the field of cultural policy.

 

Q >“You to Me, Me to You”: tell us about why you chose this title for the show?

A >As I was conceiving the exhibition, a recent memory played in my mind very much in loop for weeks already. It was a dialogue between the guy I am in love with and myself. After my love-declaration at the Ministry of Public Education in Mexico City, I asked him if he wanted to be “Fernando” to me (that’s his name), to which he responded, “only if you’ll be ‘Francisco’ to me”. Hence an exhibition title and a concept were coined.

 

Installation view: Pedro Slim, Untitled (2023). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

 

Q >In what ways has your background (someone who studied geography and political science — instead of art history) flavour your approach to this exhibition?

A >I think having studied disciplines other than Art History or Arts in general has saved me from certain dogmatism which permeates exhibition-making these days. It’s important to be informed about what’s happening today, it’s extremely important to understand how culture has been presented and how ideas have been debated throughout the past. But I appreciate being able to operate with autonomy from… let’s call it “the guild”.

Q >How do you forge (and sustain!) relationships with artists?

A >Most artists I work with are or later become my friends. As most of my friends can attest, my friendships in general are very intimate and in the queer sense of the concept, they are my family. Sean O’Toole recently pointed out that it’s starting to look as if I am forming a recurring cast with the artists I work with, and I have to say I love this idea.

Q >Learnings — with all the multitudes around love, was there any particular work which showed you a new type or texture of love? And was there any part in this curatorial project that offered you a surprising insight?

A >The multiplicity, permanence and omnipresence of love were very much explored in this project. James Ivory said at one point that it seemed like there were three possible outcomes to the story and those outcomes were all represented by one work of art: a) it was all a dream (Manuel Alvarez Bravo, The Dreamer); the character was a male hustler (Pedro Slim, Untitled); or the love is reciprocated (Kemang Wa Lehulere, I love you too”). What happened in the end, and after reconnecting with Fernando, was that the show ended as the show started, in the cleverly touching way Dexter Dalwood depicted it in his work 

FF

RE

AR

NN

CA

IN

SD

C

O

In it, one comet leaves two wakes that eventually become one celestial body to the eye. Two, became one.

Q >Language enables us to express different aspects of affection, attachment, or passion associated with the concept of “love”. Bringing love close to home, create a set of sentences that incorporates the phrases below:

A >

Love for drama.
Love of the kind which stories are made of.
In love with Fernando.
Love to me is as uniquely human as art.
Love about beauty.
Love between beings is what keeps us making life happen.

 

Francisco Berzunza. Photography by Juan Esteban Montes

 

Q >When curating a show and working with artists you are also searching for your own answers — what do you seek to unpack, share, encourage?

A >It varies depending on the project. By now, I have developed a very unique approach to curating called “emotional curating”. I am very firm in the belief that my experience allows me to speak out and the stories I’d like to tell are narrated from this particular position. I strongly disapprove today of those who weaponise the lives of others to advance their own agendas. 

Q >Predictions: what is something you strongly believe is going to come to pass.

A >I think suffering will become more visible. 

Q >What’s your favourite way to spend a weekend?

A >In the company of people. Observing and conversing. 

Q >An unexpected pleasure you’ve encountered in the last year? 

A >Holding hands. 

Q >Legacy: What do you hope to leave behind? 

A >I hope the people I love love me with the same intensity as I’ve loved them.

Installation view: Graciela Iturbide, Jardín Botánico de Oaxaca (1998–1999_2023) and Slavs and Tatars, To No One and to Two (2023). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Dexter Dalwood, Francisco Fernando (2023). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Sophie Calle, Exquisite Pain (2000). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Iñaki Bonilla, The Return to the Origin 5, 6, 7, 8 (2010_2023). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Moshekwa Langa, Index Drawing (you give me the creeps) (2004). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Dineo Seshee Bopape, a love supreme (2016). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view: Georgina Gratrix, The Insomniac (2019). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation

Installation view:: Dayanita Singh, Mona and Myself (2013). You to Me, Me to You, curated by Francisco Berzunza, 12 August–18 November 2023. Image courtesy of A4 Arts Foundation